Nestled in the heart of Plaistow, New Hampshire, Stillwells Ice Cream is a true treasure for anyone craving a rich, creamy scoop of happiness. Specializing in Richardson's Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Stillwells offers an impressive variety of flavors that perfectly blend classic favorites with unique, refreshing options. Whether you’re drawn to the indulgent Death By Chocolate, the nostalgic Bubble Gum, or the fruit-forward Raspberry Sorbet, every bite is a celebration of smooth textures and bold taste.
What makes Stillwells stand out is not just the exceptional quality of their ice cream but the sheer generosity of their portions. Customers often delight in ordering a "small" only to find it generously sized—perfect for sharing or savoring over a relaxing evening. The mini size is a clever choice for those wanting a taste without feeling overwhelmed, but honestly, who wants to hold back when faced with such delectable options?
The shop’s Summertime Specials, like the Strawberry Shortcake Sundae and Lime or Raspberry Lime Rickey, add a refreshing twist that calls to mind sun-filled afternoons and care-free summer days. For those who prefer something lighter, the frozen yogurt selections, especially the custardy French Vanilla and the chocolate chip varieties, receive heartfelt praise for their creamy texture and delightful flavors.
Stillwells Ice Cream also excels in creating an inviting atmosphere that’s both clean and calm—ideal for families, friends, or anyone seeking a sweet escape from the everyday hustle. The staff’s friendly, quick service truly enhances the experience, making you feel welcomed and valued from the moment you walk in. Many visitors have remarked on the warmth and kindness of the team, turning first-time visits into cherished traditions.
The value here is undeniable, with well-priced treats that never compromise on quality. Whether you pop in to grab a prepacked gallon of your favorite ice cream, enjoy an ice cream pie, or indulge in a creamy ice cream sandwich, you’re guaranteed a taste that is both satisfying and memorable.
In essence, Stillwells Ice Cream isn’t just an ice cream shop; it’s a community favorite where flavor, portion, and friendly service come together in perfect harmony. If you find yourself in Plaistow, don’t let the modest plaza exterior fool you – step inside for an experience that’s as delightful as the first lick of a creamy cone on a warm summer night.
Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *
Donne Marchetto
01/12/2025
Great ice cream flavors, including really good, frozen yogurts. Full range of sizes and in fact, you'll make a mistake Trying to order a small when small ends up being large. Start off with the mini size. Fair prices. Really excellent richardsons, ice cream. My favorite frozen yogurts are French Vanilla (kind of custardy) and chocolate chip
Jay Traveler
30/10/2025
Good selection of hard ice cream. Service was fast and friendly.
Brenda A. Laycock
18/10/2025
Best ice cream store! Variety of ice cream is outstanding! Clean eatery and friendly staff. Highly recommend this ice cream restaurant.
Eric G
09/10/2025
Love going here with my daughter. The staff is always friendly and the ice cream is delicious. Portions are super generous!
Yasmelly Castillo
08/10/2025
I would say this is a great place clean calmed environment. The service is great the girls are super sweet, friendly and quick. Ice cream and nice and cream good size portion for the price. Extremely recommended and grab a ducky so cute and unique. Run raisen my favorite
Becky Newkirk
01/10/2025
Go hungry! They don't have "small" portions. Oh, they have small as an option on the menu for some items, but those are still HUGE servings! A "kiddy" size is the size of most places "large". And the flavor of the ice cream is amazing. Rich, creamy, smooth... everything you're looking for in an indulgent treat at the end of your evening. They aren't shy with the toppings if you're looking for a sundae, either. The shake/frappe (as it's known in the northeast) has the correct amount of smoothness to make it up the straw, without hurting yourself or giving yourself brain freeze, too. I do wish they were open a little later, but I can't even take away a star for that, because everything else is so great, it outweighs that one negative, in my opinion. Go see what you think.
Garret
30/08/2025
Stillwells is a hidden gem in Plaistow. Don't let the plaza dissuade you, this is the best ice cream in the area. The servers are super speedy and friendly and prices are very reasonable for Richardson's ice cream. Don't miss out on the prepacked gallons, ice cream pies, or ice cream sandwiches. We're here probably more than we should be.
Jeremy Chaput
21/08/2025
This is my family's ice cream spot. We have been going here for years, the staff are always friendly and do a great job with whatever ice creams we are ordering. The price is typical for an ice cream shop and they don't skimp on the toppings. If you order a topping, they put an appropriate amount of that topping on.